Creator vetting is checking a creator's public record before you sign: the audience, how often they post, how people engage, what the comments look like and how past sponsored posts went. A follower count answers none of that. This guide covers what to check, how Superlurk's Creator vetting scorecard gathers it for one to five creators, and what a scorecard cannot tell you.
Five things to check before you sign
- Audience. How large the account is, and whether the people responding look like the people you want to reach.
- Posting rhythm. How often and how regularly the creator posts. Long gaps or sudden bursts change what a campaign slot is worth.
- Engagement. Reactions per post across recent posts, not one standout video.
- Comment patterns. Whether comments respond to the content or repeat the same generic lines.
- Sponsored-post history. Which sponsored posts the creator has published and how they were received next to ordinary posts.
How the scorecard workflow covers each
The Creator vetting scorecard takes one to five profile links for public creators on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube or X. It runs the searches, analyses what came back and reports on audience, posting rhythm, engagement, comment patterns and sponsored posts for each creator. Every claim links to the post or comment behind it.
| What it covers | Question to ask | |
|---|---|---|
| Audience | The creator's public audience | Is this the size and kind of audience the campaign needs? |
| Posting rhythm | How often and how regularly the creator posts | Would a sponsored post sit among regular content, or stand alone? |
| Engagement | Engagement on the creator's posts | Is it steady across posts, or carried by one or two? |
| Comment patterns | What the comments on those posts look like | Do people respond to the content itself? |
| Sponsored posts | Sponsored posts found in the creator's content | How did they do next to the creator's ordinary posts? |
Run it
- Collect the profile links. Paste one to five links to public profiles. Put the creators you are choosing between in the same run, so their scorecards arrive in one report.
- Read the price ceiling. The Run button shows the most the run can cost. You pay for the searches that actually run plus a 25-credit deep analysis fee, and the sample brief can cost up to 67 credits.
- Run it and open the report. A failed search is free, and if the analysis cannot be finished its fee is not charged. The report is kept for 30 days.
How to read a scorecard
- Read it creator by creator first, then compare. A scorecard describes one account's public record.
- Open the citations behind anything that would change your decision, such as a comment pattern or a weak sponsored post.
- Compare a creator's sponsored posts with the same creator's ordinary posts before you compare two creators of different sizes.
- Read the caveats. They say what could not be found or was too thin to judge.
- Write down the questions the scorecard raises and put them to the creator.
Limits to keep in mind
- Public creators only: private accounts cannot be read.
- Counts are what the first page of each search returned, not a creator's full history.
- A giveaway, a viral post or a change of format can explain a spike or a dip.
- A scorecard does not judge whether a creator suits your brand. That part is yours; see brand safety and fit.
Before vetting: build the shortlist
Vetting works on a shortlist. If you do not have one, start with Creator discovery: give it a niche and a country and it returns public creators ranked by fit, with followers, engagement per post and posting rhythm. In discovery reports, small accounts are counted, not named. Take the creators that fit and run the scorecard on up to five at a time.
After the campaign: track the posts
Once the posts are live, paste up to 30 post links into Campaign post tracker. It returns current figures in one table, with totals, best performers and how people reacted. Workflows do not repeat on their own, so run the tracker again when you want updated figures.
A scorecard does not replace asking the creator for their own analytics or agreeing disclosure terms in the contract. For a fair side-by-side method, see how to compare creators fairly, and for the other ready-made reports, the guide to research workflows.
Frequently asked questions
What should I check before signing an influencer?
Check five things from public evidence: the audience, how regularly the creator posts, how much engagement each post gets, what the comments look like, and how past sponsored posts were received.
How many creators can one scorecard run cover?
One to five public creators per run, added as profile links. The workflow covers TikTok, Instagram, YouTube and X.
Does a vetting scorecard prove that a creator's followers are real?
No. It works from public data and gives you evidence for a decision, not a verdict. Treat an unusual pattern as a question to put to the creator, and ask for their own analytics before you sign.
How this guide was written. Written by the Superlurk team on 12 November 2026 from the app's current behaviour. Examples are illustrative, not measured customer results.