Suppose a retailer wants to improve its returns process. A leaderboard of company ratings will tell the operations team little about labels, exchanges or refund delays. Choose comparable businesses first, then look for concrete accounts of the step you are trying to improve.
Define the comparison group
Take the category ID from the end of the Trustpilot category URL, such as clothing_store. In the Trustpilot category benchmark, enter the category and, optionally, up to five company websites. Use domains to distinguish businesses with similar names. Note differences in country, product type or fulfilment model that affect what a customer would experience.
The workflow lists the first category page ordered by review count. It can read the newest reviews from the companies you specify. Leaving the company list empty lets the workflow select highly rated companies from its coverage. For a repeatable comparison, supply the same domains on each run.
Read the profile and individual reviews separately
| Where to look | What to record | |
|---|---|---|
| How is the business rated? | Company profile at the time you ran the brief. | Displayed rating, review count, profile URL and observation date. |
| Which part of a return went wrong? | One page of recent reviews. | Exact words about the label, collection, tracking or refund; source URL and review date. |
| Did the case get resolved? | Any visible response or customer update. | The outcome the source actually states. Leave it open if only a promise appears. |
Turn a difference into a testable question
Imagine two reviews mention waiting for a prepaid label. That is enough to ask whether your own help page tells people when the label arrives. It gives no reliable estimate of how often returns fail for that business. Record the sample size and remember that companies can invite customers to review. Timing and invitations can change who appears in a page of recent feedback.
For a closer look at one company, continue with the review reputation audit. Keep both sets of source links if the category comparison and the single-company report are going into the same memo.
Frequently asked questions
What if the business I want is missing from the category list?
Check its public profile and website identity. Supply its domain in the brief for a named comparison, and record whether it appeared in the sampled category listing.